Godhra reports - A Travesty - Instablogs
Godhra reports - A Travesty
veena , delhi: Sep 26 2008
Made Popular Sep 26 2008
India :

Godhra reports - A Travesty

Everyone is talking about the totally different reports given for the same Godhra train fire on 25th Feb 2002 by two Supreme Court retd. eminent judges.

Is it because Banerjee Committee was appointed by the Railway Ministry headed by Lalu Prasad Yadav part of UPA government? The report clearly mentions that the fire in S6 coach was accidental not deliberate it was either an electrical fire or fire caused by cigarette butt.

As the doors of any coach cannot be locked from outside the version that petrol was poured in the coach after locking the doors from outside then set on fire is not feasible. In other words it absolves the culprits belonging to the minority community and made Gujarat Government responsible for the total breakdown of law and order situation in its aftermath Report submitted to Railway Ministry.

The Nanawati commission appointed by Gujarat Government clearly states that it was preplanned conspiracy with 140 liter of petrol used to burn the train. It absolved Modi Govt from any discrepancy or lacking in performing their duty. Report submitted to Modi Government.

As per the newspaper reports Nanawati and his son are on MOdi’s most favored list. Maulik Nanawati son of Justie Nanawati was appointed as the standing counsel for the Gujarat State in 2002 the same time as his father was appointed as the head of Godhra Committee.

All the above facts forces one to think whether we are taken for a ride. Six and a years and the actual report on Godhra is no where in sight.

Now what, another commission to sort out the differences of the above two reports, more of taxpayers’ money down the drain,but does anyone cares?

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
A cigarette does not burn a compartment.

It is quite possible that both reports are partly true.

Commissions of Inquiry are fact finding bodies and their recommendations are not binding on the government. They are not investigating agencies who are tasked to find the culprits and get them punished in a court of law.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
The key word being”Fact Finding Bodies”and fact being proveble truth, which should be proved in the court.Same evidence and same cirumstances some deviations are acceptable but total report being different not acceptable
1 Stars
Gibson
Gwalior, India
There is no doubt that the UC Bannerjee panel report was a completely biased piece shit. How on earth can two bogeys be engulfed by fire with no one able to even jump out of the eight doors while the train was stationary in Godhra?
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
I think both reports are biased and I don’t think we will know the truth ever
1 Stars
Chintan
Ambala, India
You are right! It is a travesty indeed. I share your sentiments fully that the diametrically opposite two reports in Godhra upon crores and crores of taxpayer's money shows complete indifference to people's hard work. The government must answer this and prosecute whoever was wrong.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
I don’t remember anyone being punished for wasting taxpayers money,on the other hand more money is wasted in setting another inquiry commission
1 Stars
Chandni
Allahabad, India
These two reports are now totally dubious and politically motivated. The fact that the Supreme Court of India has not dropped charges against the Godhra accused. This means that there is enough evidence to suggest that the killings too place. UC Bannerji has made a total ass of himself. He must be flogged else he should come up with the real story of political pressure.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
Both the reports are trying to please someone or the other, the truth can go take a hike
1 Stars
Yash
Bhopal, India
I guess India shall now never know the full truth behind the Godhra carnage. All hope is lost. The reports are tailor made to suit one political party or the other. This is shameful. There should be no such commissions like this from now on. Only independent commissions led by a sitting Supreme Court or High Court judge.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
You are absolutely right,we will never know the truth and the guilty will go scott free
2 Stars
Brij Lal Gupta
Bulandshahr, India
it has to be seem that Nanawati Reports is very close to actual facts while banerjee’s report is bogus.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
There is so much difference in the two reports that one is totally confused
1 Stars
Elias
Bombay, India
Veena, you are correct and covered everything from the wastage of taxpayer's money for panels and commissions coming out with two reports negating one another so that the sum total is a big zero and the public is made to look like a herd of donkeys.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
It is the same result with report of any commision,all words and no action
1 Stars
Siddhesh
Pune, India
Sickulars cannot bear the truth this time.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
The Tehalka report is non biased
1 Stars
Vijay
Kota, India
Veena,I was passing through Godhra,by Golden temple mail,just hours after the Sabarmati mail’s incidence and saw the coach from outside.It happened just after meters away from the ending of platforms.Inside or outside,whatever it may be,but the question is,those Muslims,who were waiting near railway crossing,were not having flowers in their hands.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
No one is denying the fact that violence did took place after all so many people lost their lives,only the fact finding agencies were influenced differently
1 Stars
Ikram
Dhaka, Bangladesh
The Nanavati report is a part of the larger conspiracy against religious minorities in India especially Muslims by the Hindus. Modi is a fascist leader and this report came as no surprise. Not only Muslims, but Christians are being targeted and killed in India these days.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
It is all a political game,everyone looses except those who play dirty politics at the cost of innocent people
1 Stars
Ekta
Jaipur, India
... and while we debate who was right and who was wrong and throw mud on one another indulging in slimy debates, the terrorists are blowing up our women and children with increasing audacity... India is a wretched country.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
No,Ekta,India is not a wretched country it is the people with no morals who are instigating such incidents are wretched,they should be exposed and punished
1 Stars
Ketul
Jamshedpur, India
India is a nation is cursed because we the people are the worst of our kind in the whole world. It is we who chose our leaders, it is a part of our own society that accepts and practices corruption, kills other members of the society on the basis of religion and caste.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
No we are worst people, infact we are too trusting and unable to even think that the other persn can harm us. It is because of this feeling we are unable to control the spread od terrorism
Add your Comment